by Jenna Connolly | Sep 21, 2026 | Featured News, Housing News
In a critical victory for housing justice and affordability, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court (SJC) has upheld the legality of the MBTA Communities Act and decisively dismissed the Town of Marshfield’s legal challenge. The ruling confirms once again that compliance with the state’s affordable housing law is non-negotiable and deals a decisive blow to attempts to undermine state mandates that expand access to housing.
The SJC held that the MBTA Communities Act does not violate the Home Rule Amendment of the Massachusetts Constitution and that Marshfield failed to show the Act is an unfunded mandate. This decision marks the second high-profile case in which the state’s highest court has unequivocally declared that the MBTA Communities Act is a valid exercise of the state Legislature’s power. Citizens’ Housing and Planning Association (CHAPA), Lawyers for Civil Rights (LCR), and Nixon Peabody LLP celebrate the ruling as another landmark victory in the mission to create more affordable housing opportunities across Massachusetts.
In February, CHAPA, LCR, and Nixon Peabody filed an amicus brief with the SJC on behalf of 18 housing and civil rights organizations in defense of the MBTA Communities Act.
“Today’s decision allows communities to keep moving forward by creating more homes, stronger communities, and a thriving Commonwealth,” said Eric Shupin, Chief Executive Officer of Citizens’ Housing and Planning Association (CHAPA). “The Governor, the Attorney General, 168 MBTA Communities already in compliance, and the SJC have now all made clear that noncompliance is non-negotiable. CHAPA will continue to support using all the tools our state has, including the MBTA Communities Act, so everyone can find a safe, affordable home in the communities they choose. This is a victory for housing and opportunity across Massachusetts.”
Last year, a Superior Court judge issued a comprehensive decision dismissing unfunded mandate suits brought by Marshfield and other municipalities. In that opinion and the one issued today, the courts declined to follow the state auditor’s 2025 finding that the Act is an unfunded mandate.
“This decision affirms, once again, that the MBTA Communities Act is the law of the land in Massachusetts,” said Jacob Love, General Counsel for Policy at CHAPA. “We’re hopeful that today’s victory shuts the door on further legal challenges to the Act, so that the Commonwealth can continue to create the homes that Massachusetts residents need.”
“As today’s decision confirms, compliance with the MBTA Communities Act is, and always has been, mandatory,” said Jillian Lenson, Senior Attorney at Lawyers for Civil Rights. “Massachusetts’ lack of sufficient affordable housing for families is a crisis—and one that disproportionately impacts communities of color. It is well past time for all MBTA Communities to allow for critical multi-family development. This is now settled law, and compliance must continue to ensure greater access to housing.”
Signed into law in 2021, the MBTA Communities Act requires all municipalities served by the MBTA to designate an area where property owners can legally build apartments, townhomes, and other types of mid-scale multifamily housing. As of September 2026, over 10,000 new homes (with over 1,800 of them deed-restricted) have entered the pipeline in zoning districts adopted to comply with the MBTA Communities Act, providing potentially thousands of people—families, young adults, downsizing seniors, and more—with opportunities to find homes that fit their needs in Massachusetts.
###
Citizens’ Housing & Planning Association (CHAPA) is the leading statewide affordable housing policy organization in Massachusetts. Established in 1967, CHAPA advocates for increased opportunity and expanded access to housing so every person in Massachusetts can have a safe, affordable, and welcoming place to call home in the communities they choose. For more information, visit www.chapa.org.
Lawyers for Civil Rights (LCR) works with people of color, immigrants, and low-income communities to fight discrimination, foster equity, and pursue justice through creative and courageous legal advocacy, education, and economic empowerment. In partnership with law firms and community allies, LCR provides free, life-changing legal support to individuals, families, and small businesses. For more information, visit https://lawyersforcivilrights.org/.
Nixon Peabody LLP is an American Lawyer top-100 law firm in the United States and has offices worldwide. Our firm delivers exceptional service to our clients and our communities by combining high performance, entrepreneurial spirit, deep engagement, and an unwavering commitment to a culture of collaboration and humanity. Learn more at www.nixonpeabody.com.
by Jenna Connolly | Sep 18, 2026 | Housing News
The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court has today rejected yet another challenge to the legality of the MBTA Communities Act. This decision marks the second high-profile case, following Attorney General v. Milton in early 2025, in which the state’s highest court has explicitly held that the Act is a valid exercise of the State Legislature’s power.
In dismissing the Town of Marshfield’s case, the Court made two key rulings. Most notably, it declared that the Act unequivocally does not violate the Home Rule Amendment of the Massachusetts Constitution. The Court explained that Act “addresses the Commonwealth’s housing crisis” which is a subject that “falls squarely within the Legislature’s retained authority under the Home Rule Amendment.”
Second, the Court held that Marshfield failed to present any facts at all supporting its claim that the Act constitutes an unfunded mandate. In making that point, the Court emphasized that the State Auditor’s 2025 opinion, which found that the Act is an unfunded mandate, was immaterial because it “did not identify any municipality-specific mandatory costs” imposed by the Act “much less any costs imposed on Marshfield.”
Ultimately, today’s ruling once again affirms that the MBTA Communities Act is the law of the land in Massachusetts. The Act thus remains a binding mandate for covered cities and towns to help address our affordable housing shortage by zoning for multi-family housing.
by Jenna Connolly | Jul 17, 2025 | Featured News, Housing News
On Tuesday, July 14, Attorney General Andrea Campbell issued a legal advisory informing MBTA Communities of the next steps her office will take to enforce the MBTA Communities Act. Although the final regulatory deadline to adopt compliant zoning has now passed, the Attorney General will defer litigation against non-compliant communities until January 1, 2026. This measured approach provides communities with additional time to complete the local processes required to adopt zoning bylaws by the end of 2025. Citizens’ Housing and Planning Association (CHAPA) commends the Attorney General for her commitment to enforcing this essential housing law.
“The MBTA Communities Act is an essential tool for creating the homes that people, our communities, and our economy need to thrive,” said Rachel Heller, CHAPA’s chief executive officer. “We applaud Attorney General Campbell for her commitment to enforcing state housing laws so that all people have opportunities to find homes they can afford in communities they choose. We hope that communities utilize the many resources available to implement the law, including CHAPA’s cost-free technical assistance program.”
The Executive Office of Housing and Livable Communities’ (“HLC”) original MBTA Communities Act regulations required MBTA Communities with, or adjacent to, commuter rail stations to adopt compliant multifamily zoning districts by the end of 2024. The deadline was extended to July 14, 2025. As of today, 15 communities have missed that deadline and will immediately lose eligibility for most competitive state grant funding.
Although MBTA Communities have had nearly five years to create and implement multifamily zoning plans, a period in which 139 communities—the majority—have successfully complied, CHAPA recognizes the utility of providing more time to municipalities that have struggled to implement the law. Given the amount of inflammatory rhetoric surrounding this law, the Attorney General’s advisory turns down the temperature and political pressure and serves as a gesture of goodwill, encouraging residents to design multifamily zoning districts that meet their community’s unique housing needs.
“CHAPA has worked with planners from over 80 municipalities to educate residents about the MBTA Communities Act and all but four of those communities ultimately chose to adopt multifamily zoning districts,” said Will Rhatigan, CHAPA’s MBTA Communities engagement manager. “We’re confident that every municipality can find a multifamily zoning district that satisfies their residents, and we’re ready to offer our cost-free technical assistance with community engagement to any municipality that seeks to reach compliance with the MBTA Communities Act by the end of this year.”
Communities interested in participating in CHAPA’s cost-free technical assistance program for community engagement can reach out to Will Rhatigan at [email protected].
by Will Rhatigan | Jun 6, 2025 | Featured News, Housing News
June 6, 2025 — Today, in yet another victory for the MBTA Communities Act (the “Act”), a Massachusetts Superior Court judge decisively ruled that the Act “does not constitute an unfunded mandate.” In doing so, the Court squarely rejected the State Auditor’s contrary opinion issued earlier this year and dismissed a series of municipal lawsuits citing that opinion. Those suits were always a hail mary—as Citizens’ Housing and Planning Association (“CHAPA”) argued in an amicus brief filed by Lawyers for Civil Rights (“LCR”)—and the latest Court ruling slams the door shut on their arguments. Most importantly, the decision re-affirms that all MBTA Communities must do their part to alleviate Massachusetts’ affordable housing shortage by allowing multi-family housing to be built more freely.
CHAPA and LCR celebrate this ruling as a major victory in the mission to create multi-family and reasonably-priced housing opportunities across Massachusetts, and applaud Attorney General Andrea Campbell’s steadfast defense of the Act in these lawsuits and others.
“CHAPA is thrilled that the courts have once again affirmed that the MBTA Communities Act is the law and that communities must comply,” said Rachel Heller, Chief Executive Officer of CHAPA. “Sky-high housing costs are hurting people and our neighborhoods and threaten the health of our economy. Today’s decision makes it clear that every community needs to be part of the solution.”
Although the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court held that the Act is constitutional and enforceable in Attorney General vs. Town of Milton this January, several communities recently filed lawsuits seeking exemptions from the Act in response to a determination from the State Auditor’s Division of Local Mandates (DLM) that the Act could be an unfunded mandate. Those towns include Duxbury, Hamilton, Hanson, Holden, Marshfield, Middleton, Wenham, Weston, and Wrentham.
As CHAPA and LCR expected, the Court soundly rejected these suits, concluding instead that DLM’s determination was flawed and legally non-binding, and that the Act does not impose any unfunded costs on communities. The court further agreed with our organizations that updating zoning codes and holding town meetings are regular functions of municipal government, meaning that the law’s requirement to adopt multifamily zoning districts does not create additional costs.
The court also rejected all claims that multifamily zoning districts impose infrastructure costs upon communities, concluding that any connection between multifamily zoning and increased costs for services and infrastructure is purely speculative.
“Today’s ruling is a great victory for all Massachusetts residents, but particularly the communities of color and low-income individuals hardest hit by the affordable housing crisis,” said Jacob Love, Senior Attorney at LCR. “Increasing multi-family housing stock is critical to advancing fair housing in the Commonwealth and this decision preserves one of the most important tools we have in the fight for housing equity.”
Like the courts, the majority of MBTA communities have rejected the argument that multi-family homes impose unfair costs. As of May 30th, 75 percent of MBTA Communities have embraced the opportunity to provide more reasonably-priced homes for their residents and adopted multifamily zoning districts intended for compliance with the Act.
CHAPA and LCR are gratified that the courts not only continue to endorse our legal arguments, but also reject all efforts to undermine the Act. While this law is only the first of many steps needed to make homes affordable for everyone in Massachusetts, defending it is crucial to setting the stage for all the other work we intend to do together to build more reasonably-priced homes.
###
Citizens’ Housing & Planning Association (CHAPA) is the leading statewide affordable housing policy organization in Massachusetts. Established in 1967, CHAPA advocates for increased opportunity and expanded access to housing so every person in Massachusetts can have a safe, healthy, and affordable place to call home in the communities they choose, free from discrimination. For more information, visit www.chapa.org.
Lawyers for Civil Rights fights discrimination and fosters equity through creative and courageous legal advocacy, education, and economic empowerment. With law firms and community allies, we provide free, life-changing legal support to individuals, families, and small businesses. www.lawyersforcivilrights.org
by Matt Noyes | May 15, 2025 | Housing News
Next week, the Massachusetts Senate will debate the FY2026 state budget. Among the 1058 amendments filed to the Senate Ways and Means proposal last week were several proposals that would roll back, weaken, or delay Chapter 3A – the MBTA Communities Act.
Massachusetts needs 222,000 homes by 2035 to stabilize our rental and homeownership markets. The MBTA Communities Act, passed by the Legislature in 2020 and signed into law in 2021, directs 177 cities and towns to establish multi-family zoning districts in their municipalities. To date, 131 of these communities have submitted compliance proposals to EOHLC, with many more on track to do so.
The MBTA Communities Act is a success. The multi-family zoning districts established through this law will make it possible to create many of the homes we need for Massachusetts to thrive.
The proposals to undermine this success are misguided and will only serve to set the Commonwealth back in its efforts to address our housing needs. In many cases, these are not new amendments – similar, if not identical, proposals have been made and overwhelmingly rejected during the process of developing the Affordable Homes Act, the FY2025 budget, and in the House during its FY2026 budget debate last month.
CHAPA urges the Senate to reject these amendments. If you are able, please contact your state senator and aske them to oppose these proposals:
#12 – Places New Requirements on Cities and Towns to Report on MBTA Communities Act Impact to EOHLC. This reporting would require an analysis of the impacts of housing construction on local infrastructure and schools – information that is not readily available and would be difficult to produce. If passed, this amendment would place a significant strain on scarce municipal resources without a clear benefit.
#13, #140, & #147 – Adds Unnecessary Appeal Criteria to MBTA Communities Act based on factors that are outside the scope of the law, including the availability of water, sewer, and wastewater treatment. The MBTA Communities Act does not require cities and towns to provide these sorts of infrastructure. If passed, these amendments would only delay and complicate the implementation of the law without providing a benefit to municipalities.
#141 & #296 – Narrows Definition of “MBTA Community” to exempt all communities without a rail, subway, or ferry station within its municipality from compliance with the MBTA Communities Act. If passed, it would significantly limit the number of new homes that could be permitted through the law and ignore the good-faith efforts made by nearly four dozen adjacent communities and small towns to comply with the MBTA Communities Act.
#274 & #834 – Limits the Use of Grant Funding to Encourage Compliance with MBTA Communities Act by allowing communities that choose not to do their part to address the Commonwealth’s housing challenges to avoid consequences established by the law, ignoring the good-faith efforts made by 131 communities in choosing to comply.
#297 – Delays Implementation of the MBTA Communities Act by changing the deadlines for municipal compliance. Massachusetts has faced significant housing challenges for years and cannot afford to wait any longer to address them. Given the acuity of our housing challenges, the 131 communities that have met their compliance deadlines and adopted compliant zoning, the extensive engagement and technical assistance provided to cities and towns, and the length of time needed to create the homes we need, this amendment is not only unnecessary but is harmful.
#298 – Exempts Municipalities from Compliance with MBTA Communities Law without Meeting Requirements based on factors outside of the scope of the law, including compliance with 40B and the granting of water withdrawal permits. The law is not about what is on the land now – it is about what will be allowed to be built in the future. To produce homes that people, our communities, and the Commonwealth need, local zoning needs to allow for it.
#839 – Creates A Single-Municipality Exception from MBTA Communities Law Classifications by altering the MBTA Communities Law for the benefit of one community. In creating this carve-out, the amendment goes against the broad stakeholder engagement and public comment process that informed the Law’s implementation and would be unfair to the 176 other communities subject to the Law.